23 Sep Three Ways to Make Fall Feel Like Home

Every year, fall seems to arrive in stores before it arrives outside. 

Especially if you’re still looking at 90 degree weather at the end of September! Here’s glaring at you, south Georgia…

Suddenly there are new color palettes, decorating trends, and very strong opinions about which shade of pumpkin we’re supposed to love this year.

But bringing fall into your home doesn’t mean temporarily turning it into someone else’s version of autumn. Your home already has a personality. It has colors you love, objects you’ve collected, and stories tucked into unexpected corners. If you’re anything like me, a little geekiness is woven throughout. Seasonal decorating can become another layer of that story rather than something you place on top of it.

So instead of asking how to make your existing decor work with this year’s version of fall, start with a different question:

What does fall look like in your home?

Maybe it’s warm candlelight and worn books; deep greens and natural wood. Or a favorite blanket brought back out for chilly evenings. It could be a slightly witchy corner that somehow becomes socially acceptable for several glorious months. Or subtle nods to the stories and worlds that already make your home feel like yours. Honestly, you don’t need to rearrange everything or change your style to make room for the season.

Sometimes seasons can just settle into the home you already love. And fall is no exception.

Before You Buy Another Pumpkin

Seasonal aisles make it very easy to feel like fall is something we need to recreate every year. 

(*cough* Michaels *cough*)

And don’t get me wrong – I enjoy walking up and down the aisles to see what new trends they’ve invented each year. Or brought back… But before filling a basket with whatever autumn looks like this season, we should take a look around our own homes. Pull out the things you’ve saved from previous years. Notice existing colors, textures, artwork, candles, blankets, books, and favorite objects. You may already have much of what you need to make your space feel ready for fall.

And if you discover that something really is missing?

Well then you wander into Michaels and get lost in all the seasonal goodness.

Three Ways to Bring Fall Into Your Home

• Start With What You Already Love
• Let Fall Borrow From Your Color Palette
• Decorate With a Feeling, Not a Theme

Start With the Home You Already Love

Before adding anything seasonal, look at the home that’s already there. This is how I begin most of my home decor projects.

What colors do you naturally surround yourself with? What materials show up again and again? Are there rooms you prefer to spend your time in? Maybe your home leans modern and minimal, warm and collected, colorful and playful, or—as ours does—somewhere between industrial and cozy.

Your everyday home decor doesn’t have to disappear just because fall arrives.

Instead, let your space guide the way you bring the season in. If your home is filled with natural wood and warm neutrals, autumn may slip in easily through richer textures and earthy colors. If you surround yourself with cooler tones and cleaner lines, your version of fall might look completely different.

The same goes for the geekier pieces of your home. You don’t have to put away the artwork, collections, books, or subtle references that already tell your story to make room for pumpkins and leaves. Let the season settle in around them.

Our home, for example, has slowly grown into a cozy industrial style with brick, metal, wood, plants, and the geeky pieces we’ve collected or made along the way. So when fall comes around, I don’t want our home to suddenly look like somewhere else. I want it to feel like our home in autumn.

And I think that’s the difference.

Let Fall Borrow From Your Color Palette

Fall doesn’t belong to one color palette.

Burnt orange, warm brown, cream, and deep red may be the colors we traditionally associate with the season, but you don’t have to bring all—or any—of them into your home to make it feel like autumn.

Instead, start with the colors you already love.

For years, I decorated for fall with all the colors I thought autumn was supposed to have. Orange pumpkins. Gold and brown leaves. Berries, corn, scarecrows—if it looked like fall had arrived at a farm, there was a good chance I owned it.

And I love fall, so I never really questioned it.

It wasn’t until Hubs and I began decorating a home together that I looked at everything I’d collected and realized something surprising: I didn’t feel connected to most of it.

The things I loved about fall weren’t really orange pumpkins or harvest colors. I loved the way the light changed. The first cool breeze after months of summer heat. The cooler colors outside. Sleeping better. Breathing easier. Watching everything begin to fall, close, and go to sleep.

Apparently my relationship with autumn is slightly more gothic than agricultural. And honestly? That explains a lot. 😂

When I eventually found white pumpkins, I loved how cool and quiet they felt in our home. Black details and swirling patterns followed. Eventually, The Nightmare Before Christmas gave us a wonderfully strange little visual language for something we’d already been discovering together—a version of fall that felt much more like us.

And that’s the point: Your version of fall doesn’t have to look like anyone else’s. Let the season borrow from the colors that already make your home feel like yours.

Instead of beginning with the colors we associate with the season, look at the colors already living in your home. Then ask what you love about fall. Maybe it’s the warmth of harvest season and your home comes alive with amber, rust, and gold. Maybe it’s misty mornings and changing forests, so you reach for moss, plum, charcoal, and weathered wood. Or maybe your fall is black, white, green, and just a little bit spooky.

Your palette doesn’t have to prove that it’s fall. It only has to help your home feel like fall to you.

The goal isn’t to find a more stylish version of traditional fall. It’s to figure out which parts of the season actually feel like fall to you. 

Decorate With a Feeling, Not a Theme

Themes can be fun, but they also make it very easy to start decorating from a checklist.

Choose a theme, and suddenly you’re looking for all the things that belong to it. Pumpkins. Signs. Figurines. Matching pillows. A coordinating wreath. Before long, you’re not necessarily choosing things because you love them—you’re choosing them because they complete the theme.

And that’s how we tumble headfirst into tchotchke-ism. 

Instead, think about the feeling you’re trying to create.

A favorite story, game, or fictional world can be a wonderful place to begin, especially when you’re decorating with subtle fandom. But rather than recreating that world in your living room, ask yourself what draws you to it in the first place. Is it mysterious? Cozy? Whimsical? A little eerie? Does it make you think of candlelit libraries, misty forests, warm taverns, old castles, or evenings spent adventuring somewhere far away?

Then borrow from that feeling.

For us, The Nightmare Before Christmas eventually became part of the language of fall. But that doesn’t mean turning our home into Halloween Town every September. I love the swirling shapes, black and white details, gothic whimsy, and slightly strange feeling of that world. Those elements already work beautifully with the cooler, darker version of autumn that I love—and they can settle naturally into the industrial, cozy home Hubs and I have created together.

Someone unfamiliar with the movie might simply see a home that feels a little moodier for fall. 

But someone who knows?

They know.

And that’s one of my favorite things about subtle geek decor. You don’t have to recreate a fandom to live with the feeling it gives you. Sometimes a color, texture, shape, piece of artwork, or tiny unexpected detail is enough to bring a little bit of that story into your home.

And if an all-out themed room genuinely makes you happy? Just ignore me and build the Beetlejuice living room of your dreams! The point isn’t subtlety for subtlety’s sake. It’s knowing what you actually love. 

Let Fall Feel Like Yours

There isn’t one right way for a home to look in autumn.

Your fall may feel like warm oranges, baskets of apples, plaid blankets, and a table overflowing with pumpkins. Maybe it’s cool greens, white pumpkins, black candlesticks, and something just a little strange tucked onto a shelf. Or perhaps you barely decorate at all, but instead bring out a heavier blanket, light a moody candle, and reach for that mug that somehow only feels right once the air turns cool. What matters is that you recognize yourself in it.

Our home doesn’t look the way I once thought a home was supposed to look for fall. And honestly, I’m glad it doesn’t. Over time, Hubs and I figured out which colors, objects, traditions, and tiny bits of weirdness actually belong to us and in our space. Some came from stories we love. Others came from things we’ve collected together. And all of it simply came from paying attention to how we want our home to feel.

That’s the lovely thing about decorating with the seasons. Your home doesn’t have to become somewhere else for a few months. It can simply become the autumn version of itself. And sometimes understanding what you love takes time. It takes some trial and error – but eventually you’ll find that feeling.

So pull out those things you’ve missed. For me, it’s sweaters and my favorite cauldron mug. Move your favorite blanket back to the couch. Light the candle. Place that slightly spooky thing that makes you smile. Let the evenings get darker and the rooms get cozier.

And then? Well then just leave a little room for the season to do the rest.

If you liked this post, I think you’ll love:

Also browse This Geek Life Shop for handmade art for your home to celebrate Falloween and Spooky Season!